The Top Marketing Problems Facing Faith-based Organizations in 2025

Faith-based organizations face a set of marketing challenges that are critical yet rarely discussed.

While the focus often centers on trendy topics like digital engagement and influencer strategies, there are deeper, more complex issues that remain overlooked. These challenges are essential for the future success of faith-based outreach and community building, but they aren’t getting the attention they deserve.

This list highlights the most pressing, yet underappreciated, marketing problems that will shape the direction of faith-based organizations in the coming year.

 

 

GUIDE: Six 2025 Marketing Challenges Facing Faith-based Organizations

 

1. Attracting Younger Generations Without Compromising Core Values

• Problem: Engaging millennials and Gen Z is a major concern for faith-based organizations, as younger generations often feel disconnected from traditional religious practices. While the challenge of engaging young people is widely acknowledged, the less visible issue is how to do so without softening or altering core doctrinal messages. Many young adults are drawn to issues like social justice, inclusion, and environmental sustainability. However, aligning with these interests while remaining true to traditional faith teachings presents a tension that is difficult to navigate.
• Why It’s Overlooked: Much of the public conversation focuses on tactics like increasing digital outreach or creating more engaging youth programs, but there’s less discussion about the doctrinal compromises some fear could result from this shift. The conversation tends to oversimplify the issue as one of “better marketing” rather than acknowledging the deeper struggle of retaining theological integrity while appealing to the values of younger audiences.

 

2. Balancing Tradition with Digital Transformation

• Problem: Faith-based organizations often struggle to adopt new technologies without compromising the essence of their traditions. Integrating digital tools like social media, live streaming, or online donations can be difficult for congregants who prefer in-person services and traditional modes of worship. Leaders often face resistance when attempting to bring technology into sacred spaces, as some members see this as a dilution of spiritual experiences or a threat to the personal connections they’ve cultivated in physical settings.
• Why It’s Overlooked: The focus on digital innovation is more visible in business and entertainment sectors, but faith-based organizations aren’t typically seen as tech-forward entities. Because the conversation about digital transformation is so often tied to financial or operational efficiency, the spiritual and communal aspects that define faith communities are underappreciated. This creates a gap in understanding the deeper resistance from within the community, making it seem like a secondary issue when it’s actually quite foundational.

 

3. Local Relevance in a Globalized Online Environment

• Problem: With an increasing shift to online platforms, many faith-based organizations struggle to maintain their relevance in local communities. The challenge is that online outreach often feels detached from the specific needs, culture, and character of local congregations. Without a strong local presence, faith organizations risk losing their direct impact on the community. Faith communities traditionally provide support, social services, and moral guidance within a defined geographic area, and moving much of their operations online can diminish this local connection.
• Why It’s Overlooked: In the rush to keep up with global communication trends, there’s an emphasis on scaling outreach, often ignoring the importance of grassroots, place-based marketing. The scalability and efficiency of online engagement overshadow the value of hyper-local involvement, which can make the problem appear less urgent. Many organizations focus their marketing efforts on reaching broad audiences rather than honing in on their unique local context, which often leads to an underappreciation of the issue.

 

4. Funding and Donor Engagement Amid Economic Uncertainty

• Problem: Economic instability has created significant challenges for donor engagement. Traditional fundraising methods, such as in-person appeals or offering plates during services, are less effective as congregants face financial constraints. Additionally, many faith-based organizations are slow to adopt new fundraising technologies like mobile apps, recurring online donations, or transparent reporting tools. This reluctance to modernize fundraising methods can limit the ability to sustain essential programs and services.
• Why It’s Overlooked: The discussion around nonprofit and faith-based fundraising tends to focus on high-profile donor campaigns or one-time large gifts, while ignoring the smaller, ongoing contributions that are critical for day-to-day operations. Additionally, economic uncertainty is often perceived as a temporary issue, rather than a persistent one, leading many organizations to rely on outdated models with the hope that things will eventually return to “normal.” As a result, the conversation doesn’t emphasize long-term sustainability strategies.

 

5. Maintaining Volunteer Engagement in a Post-Pandemic World

• Problem: Faith-based organizations heavily rely on volunteer engagement to run programs, but volunteer fatigue is a growing issue. Many people who stepped up during the pandemic are now feeling burnt out, while others who stopped volunteering during lockdowns haven’t returned. Furthermore, the nature of volunteering has shifted, with fewer opportunities for in-person interaction and more reliance on digital platforms or remote service, which can make it harder to foster a sense of community.
• Why It’s Overlooked: Volunteer fatigue is often treated as a temporary hurdle that will resolve itself as the pandemic becomes more distant. There’s a mistaken belief that as normal activities resume, so will volunteerism. However, this fails to acknowledge that many volunteers are now hesitant to return, either due to ongoing health concerns or lifestyle changes that emerged during the pandemic. The long-term nature of volunteer fatigue and its implications for community engagement and service provision is often downplayed.

 

6. Ethical Marketing Dilemmas in Faith Messaging

• Problem: Faith-based organizations face unique ethical concerns when marketing their messages and services. There is a fine line between persuasive marketing and manipulation, especially when appeals are made for donations or emotional responses. For example, using strong emotional appeals in fundraising campaigns can sometimes feel exploitative, particularly if congregants feel guilt-tripped into giving. Additionally, the growing use of social media influencers or emotionally charged video content can raise questions about whether the focus has shifted too much towards entertainment over spiritual edification.
• Why It’s Overlooked: Ethical dilemmas in marketing often receive less attention because the industry tends to focus on results—such as increased attendance or donations—without questioning the methods used to achieve those outcomes. The emphasis on growth metrics tends to obscure the nuanced conversations that should be happening around ethical concerns. Moreover, marketing success stories that showcase increased engagement are celebrated, leaving little room for reflection on whether those tactics align with the core values of the faith organization.

 

 

Get Help Tackling 2025 Faith-Based Marketing Challenges

Leaders in faith-based organizations will face a distinct set of marketing challenges, from balancing tradition with digital innovation to navigating ethical dilemmas in outreach strategies.

Many of these critical issues (though largely ignored) will require immediate attention and thoughtful solutions to stay relevant and maintain community engagement.

Addressing these challenges with proactive strategies can strengthen connections with congregants, ensure long-term sustainability, and preserve the integrity of their mission in an increasingly complex environment.

 

GET MARKETING HELP FOR FAITH-BASED ORGANIZATIONS »